This kicks off a week of writing-related posts. Rejected, how could I not make this about writing? Here’s my picture:
You hear a lot about rejection from newbie and aspiring writers because to them it’s a big deal. There is no way to completely divide your emotions from your work. Yet the world demands that we suddenly stop caring about our work once we submit it. We can’t help thinking about how we’re going to spend that money or how good it will feel to have that credit, to see your name in print whether for the first time, or again. And we believe in our story with that shaky belief that we think it’s as good as the stuff we’ve read, so hopefully the editor will too.
So rejections are crushing, because we only see it from our side, from the point of view of what that sale would mean to us.
Now I’m going to ask you to see it from the other side with a nifty little analogy. Let’s say you have a fierce craving for a sweet snack, so you head out to the grocery store to pick something up. Now “sweet snack” does narrow what you’re looking for down some. You know you can skip the meat isle and the condiment aisle, and the cleaning supply and pet food aisles. But it’s still really vague when you get to the store. I mean, there’s candy, or fruit, or yogurt, or even breakfast cereal or granola bars, ice cream or bottles of juice.
So you browse, because you had narrowed what you were looking for, but there’s just so much in the slush pile I mean, grocery store. Something you know right off aren’t right for you. I don’t like nuts in my ice cream, and most candy makes me sick to my stomach after more than a “fun sized” portion. I can toss out anything the store has priced too high (though that part of the analogy doesn’t apply to markets, who usually put their pay rates out front and center), or that looks sketchy, is in packages too big, or that I know I won’t enjoy again later (let’s face it most packages and stories both should be good for multiple servings).
I still have way more options than I could possibly buy. And yeah, I don’t have to just buy one thing, but I can’t buy it all. The idea, when you’re on the end putting out the money–even if it isn’t your own–of feeling obligated to buy or guilty for not buying everything that fits the description of what they’re looking for is just silly. You don’t feel guilty when you grab the Oreos and not all the cookies on the shelf. You can’t. (Although, let’s face it there are some commercials and such that do operate on guilt and pressure.) And you certainly don’t feel guilty if you pass a nice thick T-bone that looks delicious, but doesn’t suit the purpose of your shopping trip. No matter how awesome it looks, it’s just not a sweet snack.
Yes, we start out with out hearts on our pages, desperately wanting that validation that we’re not wasting our time writing. But there comes a point where it just clicks and rejections are just like a consumer passing you up in your nifty packaging on the grocery shelf for something they want more. It doesn’t stop being a bit of a bummer, because you submit to places you want to be published by. But it’s not just not personal. It’s not just “a part of the game”.
Rejections usually mean nothing other than “Not this market at this time”. They don’t mean “This is shit” or “You suck” and lots of big magazine and major projects give form rejections. Notes and rewrite requests are a nice little bonus, but it’s not something everyone has time for. (Heck, sending rejections period isn’t something all markets or agents have the time for. Two books of mine queried two years apart showed a massive difference in nonresponses, even among agents who claim to answer every email on their website. And yes I sent follow up emails as well, which also went very unanswered.)
Rejections are nothing because they do not define your work, and unlike the snacks on the shelf your story isn’t going to go bad. A little spit shine can freshen up a story that’s been sitting around, even after years. Your product is done, and shelf stable, and even if no one wants to buy it now, a few years will change everything. Even if you aren’t in higher demand, tastes and markets change too.
Rejection is part of writing, part of life. Under the dazzling, squee-worthy strength of even one or two sales the rejections mean nothing but “Try again”.






























