October 3

Supernatural Veterinary Science: Good God, don’t do that!

My dayjob and writing life will collide this weekend at Imaginarium in Louisville, KY. I’ll be teaching a writing class on applying biology (vet medicine/animal behavior science/epidemiology). Coincidentally, I’ve also been reading Hounded by Kevin Hearne. I was recommended to me by a number of people who probably thought I’d like it because the main character Atticus has a side kick–namely an Irish Wolfhound he can communicate with telepathically.

But I’m not enjoying it. Kind of not at all. First, I’m not huge into Irish mythos. But that’s not hard to overcome. Second, Atticus is a smug, cocky, child-man. Third the story the author tells is sexist (every woman either sleeps with the hero, for no reason, or if they won’t they’re probably unattractive, or an evil shrew) and the writing doesn’t show Atticus as a clever man worthy of the gift of immortality or attention from the gods. Instead it cuts all the “foe” characters down into even stupider, flatter beings to keep the hero from ever being in real danger. (I mean, when facing down with a legendary, goddess-favored warrior, Atticus literally pushes him over the invisible dog behind him so that he trips and falls and Atticus can behead him.)

Then, we have the dog. Oberon is a great name. And it’s the greatest part of him. While Atticus has gifted Oberon with some intelligence and telepathic communication through his friendship it’s just that Oberon isn’t a dog. The character is a dumb human, to put it in D&D terms a troll or kobold, in dog form.

The. Dog. Makes. Pop. Culture. References. The dog uses very human slang. Sarcasm. The dog talks about watching The Wizard of Oz.

This is my suspension of disbelief; broken.

While there are some studies that show that dogs will watch TV we know that they don’t see the color range that we do, they perceive “moving pictures” differently (they are faster than us, so what is moving TV to us is jerky animated pictures to them), and they just don’t stay interested long enough. Their attention span is way more active. While they might be drawn to a noise or sudden movement the lack of other sensory excitement (smell, taste, etc) causes them to lose interest fast. Dogs will cuddle on the couch with you. They will follow your gaze instinctively (like other humans do), but once that “alert” period is not further engaged they stop really paying attention.

And even if a dog actually physically watched the television for a whole movie, they don’t think in “plot” terms like we do. They can learn action and reaction (thus learning commands and the whole “looking guilty” thing), but they wouldn’t have much of a understand of the concept of stories, or stories following the same plot. Much less enough to make accurate comparisons of immediate activity to it.

This seems like a small thing to harp on, but this is really just an example of an ongoing problem. The dog also uses language like a human would. Sentence structure, even paragraph structure. And correct grammar, like verb tenses. Dogs are as mentally developed as two year olds, which is impressive! But Oberon does NOT talk like a 2 year old.

Early in the book the goddess of the hunt drives Oberon to kill a man. This is supposed to drive some of the story, but it does in all the wrong ways for me. Atticus slaps an invisibility spell on Oberon and consults with a lawyer on…how to help his dog avoid the lawful consequences of his actions.

I understand wanting to protect your dog against being put down. (I really, really, really understand that.) But the way it is written 1) Atticus completely avoids questioning whether he or other people are safe around his dog 2) avoids a metric ton of the actual emotional impact of the issue by dismissing the target as “a set up bad guy” and the reasoning as “magic powers took the dog over”.  I immediately wondered who does the awesomely clever Druid who has charms for everything, somehow NOT have a charm to protect his beloved dog from being influenced by the fae/gods who he knows are trying to kill him??

Of course, there are a number of in the open slaughtering where people who have no clue blatantly cover for Atticus as well, to the point of being completely okay with murder and cover up. (I mean his neighbor gets lemonade for him while he goes to bury a body in her back yard.)

I put the book down for almost a month. I picked it up again, hoping it was just a mood, but no, I’m struggling. What I commonly do at this point is read reviews to see if these issues resolve themselves. If there is a chance, I’ll keep reading. The reviews say there is no chance. (Not until book three. But frankly, I don’t have three books of money and time to wait for things to get good.) In fact, the reviews said some other things which bothered me.

I know that this is a fiction series that isn’t even trying to be realistic. But in the end Atticus “rewards” Oberon for being a good boy by buying him 5 in heat poodles.

So, I’ll cover rape briefly. I do believe dogs can consent. Any breeder can tell you a female dog can make her lack of interest in a male very clear. But INFORMED consent is different. 2 year olds, and dogs, don’t do clear informed consent.

But that’s not my issue (though it was an issue with other readers). My issue is…

This is an Irish Wolfhound.

This is a herd of adorable Irish Wolfhounds.

This is a standard poodle, the largest classification of poodles.

The Iris Wolfhound is the tallest of the breeds. the AKC standard says males should be at least 32 inches at the shoulder and around 120 pounds. The breed standard for poodles says female poodles should weigh 40-50 pounds max. Less than half the size. And In Heat means fertile. Ready to breed. Intent to breed. Atticus gifted his wolfhound with five females ready to breed who in the real world would be less than half his size.

Those breeding would be incredibly dangerous and likely deadly for the females. What ridiculous kind of asshat would think it’s okay to buy a bunch of dogs as a reward for his dog, when that reward would likely very seriously harm or kill them??

I mean, let’s set aside the fact that dogs are more smell and taste-centered than us, and not likely at all to fixate sexually on a certain breed’s appearance.

What kind of “hero” treats human women like trash, goddess like vapid, sexy-child-conquests, and female dogs like sacrifices? Honestly, not one I want to spend a lot of time reading about.

So this is a timely reminder (and example) of what I’m trying to teach other authors about. It’s not that science is so very important in speculative fiction. But it’s pretty clear to me that the careless treatment of animal characters and the lack of attention to decent (or even decently fake) science are not isolated writing issues, but mirror issues with the human characters, setting, and plot. It’s just one more way we, as authors can double check ourselves and build lovely, complex tales for readers.

Category: Business, Not My Work, rants and rage | Comments Off on Supernatural Veterinary Science: Good God, don’t do that!
September 24

Dear DC Comics,

*Just a note. Thanks for the link to Felica Day and io9.com and everyone else. I’m stunned by the response. Also I’m approving comments as I can and will approve any comment that isn’t spam or hateful.threatening or outright insulting of myself, my daughter or any commentor here. I adhere to the John Scalzi commenting policy. Please feel free to disagree with our opinion, because that’s what reader feedback is all about. And thanks!

 

I’m not going to rant like Comics Alliance (though you need to read it), or this one by Andrew Wheeler (also an excellent read), Ms. Snarky says it really well too (Go, read, DC editors. Take notes.)

Instead I’m going to hand over my forum and let someone else speak for me. Pay attention, DC. This is my 7 year old daughter.

And for good measure this is my 7 year old daughter as she falls asleep most nights, reading.

They’re both your books, DC. And furthermore she bought them both with HER money. Her allowance, her birthday and Christmas money. She gets at least one graphic novel and one book for major holidays. She buys superhero movies (we’ve managed to see all the major releases this year except Green Lantern and she’s loved them all.) She has a full-sized cardboard cut out of Spiderman guarding her bookshelf.

Most importantly? Starfire is her favorite hero.

So today I showed her your rebooted Catwoman and Starfire. She is not happy with you DC.

“Why do you like Starfire?”

“She’s like me. She’s an alien new to the planet and maybe she doesn’t always say the right thing, or know the right thing to do. But she’s a good friend, and she helps people. She’s strong enough to fight the bad guys, even when they hurt her. Even her sister tried to kill her, but Starfire still fights for the good side. And she helps the other heroes, like Superboy and Robin and Raven.

“She’s smart too. And sometimes she gets mad, but that’s okay because it’s okay to get mad when people are being mean. And she’s pretty.”

“What do you think about her costume?” (Referring to the outfit on the right)

“Well, she’s a grown up in that picture, not like in the Teen Titans cartoon, so if you’re a grown up and you want to wear something like that you can. It’s okay.”

“Tell me about that Starfire.”

“That’s where she’s starting the Teen Titans again. She’s helping the kids learn how to use their power and not be as sad because their friends died. She even protects them from grownups who want to tell them what to do.”

“Does that outfit make her pretty?”

“Well, no. It shows lots of her boobs though.”

“What does make her pretty?”

“Her long, pretty hair.”

“What about this Starfire? What do you think about her?” (Referring to image on the left from DC’s reboot Red Hood and the Outsiders)

“I can see almost all of her boobs.”

“And?”

“Well she is on the beach in her bikini. But…”

“But?”

“But, she’s not relaxing or swimming. She’s just posing a lot.” *my daughter appears uncomfortable*

“Anything else?”

“Well, she’s not fighting anyone. And not talking to anyone really. She’s just almost naked and posing.”

“Do you think this Starfire is a good hero?”

“Not really.”

“Do you think the Starfire from the Teen Titans cartoon is a good role model?”

*immediately* “Oh yes. She’s a great role model. She tells people they can be good friends and super powerful and fight for good.”

“Do you think the Starfire in the Teen Titans comic book is a good role model?”

“Yes, too. She’s still a good guy. Pretty, but she’s helping others all the time and saving people.”

“What about this new Starfire?”

“No, I don’t think so.”

“Why not?”

“Because she’s not doing anything.”

“Is this new Starfire someone you’d want to be when you grow up?”

*she gets uncomfortable again*”Not really. I mean, grown ups can wear what they want, but…she’s not doing anything but wearing a tiny bikini to get attention.”

“So, you know I’m going to put this on my blog right? (she nods) Is there anything else you want to say?”

“I want her to be a hero, fighting things and be strong and helping people.”

“Why’s that?”

“Because she’s what inspires me to be good.”

See, it’s not about what they’re wearing, though that can influence things. What makes a hero is WHO they are, the choices they make and the things they do. If my 7 year old can tell what you’ve done from looking at the pictures (there is no way I’m going to let her in on the whole emotionless random, amnesiac sex plot line) why can’t you see the problem here?

If this is your attempt at being edgy and reaching out the huge female comic audience out here then I look forward to when this crap collapses around you so someone who gets it can take your place. We’re looking for good stories and great heroes. This just isn’t it.

April 3

Autism & Me: Advocating for your child

Put simply, you have to. Like parenting, no one else can do it for you, and no one else can do it as well for your child as you.

Even if you have faith in your child’s teachers and the administration of the school you have to be involved, because you never know what it going on.

My son started school in August 2005. It was a huge transition, complicated by the fact that he wasn’t diagnosed yet, so the school had to legally treat him like every other kid, no ammenities. It was a struggle, in part because he had no clue how to do social school things (like ask to go to the bathroom. He would just drop his pants and walk toward the in room bathroom.) But he knew all his letters, shapes, colors and numbers and had started very basic reading and adding. He was ahead and behind at the same time. So he was equal parts frustrated and bored.

At the beginning of 2006 he was diagnosed and began getting badly needed support, like speech and outside of the class social lessons. He’s always done better one on one, so he began, in many ways, to catch up. More importantly, he began to see that school wasn’t us kicking him out of the house for eight hours a day. It was puzzling, challenging and fun.

Over the summer break something fantastic happened. He got bored. And being bored he started to want to go back to school, where there was always something to do. He was ready, we thought.

Except they put him in a class with a teacher who had no autism training, under a principal who thought he was a self punishing retard, a “school manager” who boasted that he didn’t have autism at all… and there were other problems. Things fell apart quickly. There were personel problems, communication problems, training problems…put simply everyone thought they knew better than me because they had training and I didn’t. A few thought they were going to “cure” my son and were bitterly disappointed to discover that they didn’t have a clue. The administration didn’t train or support the teacher, yet came down very hard on her for failing to control my son. The people who were supposed to be supporting him dismissed him as too much trouble, or a “retard” even to the point where we were once urged to give up on him, put in him a home “with other people like him” and get on with our lives.

His IEP (a lesson plan, which defines what ammenities a special needs child gets, which include things from a wheelchair to extra time for tests, to extra bathroom breaks or speech class) and BIP (Behavior Intervention Plan) were comepletely ignored.

I was not told until a month AFTER the problems began. Then the teacher began sending my son to the office, so they could experience hos behavior first hand. And the office, not giving a damn, sent him home. He came home early two to three times a week. And he learned that if he misbehaved (which degraded into violence) he would get sent home, he’s get to leave a situation that was incredibly stressful for him, people who he couldn’t communicate with, who yelled at him, and physically fought with him and overall made every day hell.

So guess what he did? Yeah, he hit, a lot. He kicked. He bit if those things failed. We had IEP meetings. We brainstormed. We tried new things. I was told they were trying new things, when in reality they just started putting him on the computer, or sending him to the class of people he liked to get him to shut up.

Then, one day they called an emergency IEP meeting. Those assholes got twelve–TWELVE–people to sit me down and go around the room one person at a time and tell me–only me–how horrible and uncontrollable my child was, and that they were sending him to another school. (and I also found out how badly they were treating him, and how they were ignoring the IEP because I wasn’t the autism expert. The autism expert, BTW, was too hung up on “don’t let him wear that lanyard (we used a lanyard with an id holder and a card in it to give him smilies for immediate rewards) because he can’t think that it’s okay for boys to wear necklaces” to offer anything actually useful.

Those days were real bad. They jerked me around on where he’d be going, among other things. One morning when I was getting him ready for school he broke down and begged me not to make him go. And I’d been sick to my stomach at the thought of looking at those people again, so it came as a relief. I don’t know who broke down worse, him or me, but it was bad. And part of it was my fault, because I had trusted them to do their jobs and I have believed them when they didn’t deserve it.

But you know what, moving schools was probably the best thing to happen to us.

In January 2006 he moved to a new school, one that is a third hearing impaired/deaf kids, so the whole school is familiar with handling special needs children. His teacher was way different. First he looked at my son as a challenge, someone who needed help, not someone taking up all his time who was useless and not capable anyway.

And over two years his new teacher might not have gotten him caught up to his grade level, but he did something far more important, he restored my son’s faith in teachers.

But this past fall be encountered problems again, that changed how we deal with those dealing with my son. After my trip to Context my son had two meltdowns, bad ones, in school. The administration once again brought up the idea of changing schools (thought this time is was much different). However, not only was the intention different, I was different. I was not opening myself up to another 12 person pile on, or anything that happened the first time around.

Seven Counties, a mental health advocacy and assistance group here in Louisville, offers case managers, that is a social worker whose job it is to come to your house every month and talk about what your family needs, how school and behavior, etc is going and more. I signed up after my son switched school and the first thing I did was call my case manager and tell him everything. He in turn did everything from talk with me, look up options, keepe me calm when I started panicking, remembering what happened last time. And he got us in touch with a behavoralist who went into the classroom and gave us a non-biased opinion of what my son needed, and was or wasn’t getting in the class.

The bad news was, again, his IEP and BIP. But this time the problem was that the methods the experts and professionals were telling us to use weren’t working with my son. But the teacher’s hands were tied because the system demanded certain things from him and those things were the behavioral equivilent of genre tropes. He has autism, use social stories (which never worked with my son). He has behavioral problems, give him a reward system (which was hard to impliment since his #1 reward isn’t candy or high fives or stickers, it’s a break from work.)

My son was also in a classroom mostly intended for mildly mentally retarded kids, that heavily depended on rote learning, repetition. Not to mention one teacher to ten kids, all of whom were prone to meltdowns, and the fact that my son was only a problem when you tried to get him to do work. Left to his own devices he was wonderfully behaved.

So again, he was suffering, not emotionally or mentally, but academically. And because I trusted the people dealing with him, I just let the situation go. (Still, I don’t think it was the teacher’s fault. His hands were tied and the system just wasn’t listening to him.)

We were presented options, and funnily enough, some things were kept from us. There were three people who where strongly pushing for him to move schools again. We were ready to fight it, tooth and nail, until someone finally told us that his school actually had the classification of class that they wanted to move him to, and not only was it next door to my son’s current (at that time) classroom, but he was already familiar with and working with the teacher.

The administration outright tried to push us into changing schools (where none of the people present would have to deal with my son) while his actual teachers sa quietly by, completely wrapped up in bullshit public school politics. They couldn’t help without threatening their jobs.

Which is why it’s our job to advocate for our children. Because other people literally cannot. You cannot depend on teachers, administrators ,etc to advocate for you because you do not know what they are told, or threatened with, when you aren’t looking.

I am pleased to say that I wrote up a list of demands, and my reasoning for them, and walked into that IEP meeting with my case manager, the behavioralist, and my husband all with me. We cut off every protest, every excuse, every “but” that they had. We gave them our demands and…They backed down. They stopped pushing. Like a submissive dog they completely changed how they were dealing with us.

I’m not kidding, they went from essentially telling us that we didnt know what was best for our child and were going to harm him by not moving him, to appologizing and making up excuses for their own behavior.

A month later I walked in to another meeting, with another list of demands. See, they (meanting those three “experts”, not the acutal teachers) resented the behaviorlist’s contibutions. In fact, they blocked him from visiting the class for a follow up, and tried to exclude him from the meetings. (I had to call him and invite him on my own to make sure he knew when the meeting was.) they refused to read his report. They repeatedly told me they didn’t need him, because they had their own autism expert (remember, another professional who is bound by the school system she worked for).

So I wrote down all the methods he had, in my own words, with language like “The teachers and staff will…” I demanded that some things that they were insisting on (like those social stories, which as it turned out they knew didn’t work and were pushing to “prove” my son couldn’t be where he was then) be abandoned and other things be instituted.

And they backed down on every single one and gave me exactly what I wanted. And now my son is doing fabulous. His first teacher at this school taught him to trust adults, and his current teacher has the training and respect to bring out the best in him. Next month instead of going to an IEP meeting I’ll be going to a plain old Parent-Teacher Conference. Nothing’s wrong, and I just want to keep it that way.

So to sum up, you have to advocate for your child because the administration often has only their work load in mind, and the teachers are limited to what they can do. The experts are also school employees, and are often looking for a one answer fits all solution, which is not how people work, and definitely not how autism works.

You have to go in, because a teacher asking for help gets none, but a parent going in and demanding it is the most fear creature in a school these days. So it’s our job not to be friends to the teachers, or understanding with the administration. We cannot just hand our children off to the shcool and hope for the best. It’s our jobs to make sure they get the best that they can. It’s our job to demand more from the school system, because left alone, we’ll never get it.

Category: autism, Personal, rants and rage | Comments Off on Autism & Me: Advocating for your child